Search

American Integrity share sale targets $69 million

Filing details policy takeouts and the company’s recent profitability trends

Insurance News

By Jonalyn Cueto

Nov 21, 2025Share

Shareholders of American Integrity Insurance Group Inc. launched a secondary public offering Wednesday that could generate $69 million, the insurer announced.

The offering is priced at $20 per share, with sellers offering 3 million shares and a 30-day option to purchase an additional 450,000 shares. The company expects the offering to close Nov. 21, though American Integrity will not receive any proceeds from the sale.

The secondary offering follows an initial public offering in early May, when American Integrity priced shares at $16 each. The company offered 6.25 million shares, while selling shareholders offered 625,000 shares in that transaction.

Are you an insurance innovator? Tell us — we want to hear your story

Founded in 2006, American Integrity has concentrated on Florida’s residential property insurance market. The carrier wrote 94.5% of its policies in force in Florida at the close of the third quarter, according to a Nov. 19 filing with the US Securities and Exchange Commission.

The company recently expanded into commercial residential property, providing coverage for condominiums, townhomes, and residential homeowners associations in Florida, BestWire reported.

In mid-November, American Integrity reported taking out 7,087 policies from Citizens Property Insurance Corp., Florida’s insurer of last resort. The move added approximately $25.8 million in annualized written premium. The company assumed 68,844 policies from Citizens in 2024 and 25,895 over the first three quarters of 2025, according to the SEC filing.

“We believe we identified and addressed Florida-wide residential insurance litigation trends earlier than many of our competitors, which has contributed to multiple years of strong underwriting outperformance compared to the broader Florida residential property insurance industry,” American Integrity stated in the filing.

The company noted that while the industry experienced more than $6.9 billion in underwriting losses between 2017 and 2024, American Integrity remained profitable in all but two years during that period and generated cumulative net income of $121.2 million.

“Florida’s reforms restored clarity, predictability and fairness to a market that had been destabilized by litigation abuse,” chief executive officer Bob Ritchie said. “As conditions improve, American Integrity is leaning into opportunities where we can grow responsibly.”

Shares traded at $19.27 on the afternoon of Nov. 20, down 7.18% from the previous close

Related Stories

  • American Integrity takes over 7,000 Citizens policies as private market gains ground
  • American Integrity Q2 premiums surge as policy growth outpaces forecasts